“Mass, Energy, and the Great c² Swindle”

(Neutering Einstein’s Holy Bull)

By Bodhangkur

Physicists love mystery.
They need it.
Without it, they’d have nothing to write grant applications about.

Which is why they keep pretending that mass, energy, and that sacred ox c² are profound, metaphysical revelations handed down from the Mount Sinai of Relativity.

Let’s puncture that balloon.

1. Mass Isn’t Mysterious. It’s Just Confined Action.

You’ve been told since childhood that mass is “matter,” a kind of cosmic stuff.
Wrong.

Mass is action that got trapped.

A quantum tries to race off at the universal speed limit, hits itself, and ends up sitting there sulking as realness.
That’s it.

No Higgs metaphysics.
No quantum field gospel.
Just action in a cage.

But say that at a physics conference and watch the room freeze.
They prefer their mass wrapped in thousand-page mathematics like a mummy in bandages—the same corpse underneath, just better decorated.

2. Energy: Mass Without Its Jail Cell

Energy is the same action, but given legs.

It’s the quantum allowed to run free, unconfined, shouting “Look at me!” at precisely c, the only speed nature allows for undiluted enthusiasm.

So mass and energy are not enemies, nor cousins, nor convertible currencies.
They are the same event in two emotional states:

· Energy: action unconfined

· Mass: action confined

That’s the whole story.

Half the physics community could retire if they admitted this.

3. And Now the Punchline: c² Isn’t a Genius Idea — It’s an Error Message

Einstein stuck c² into his formula like a magician dropping a rabbit into a hat he hasn’t shown the audience yet.

Physicists then spent a century applauding.

What is c²?
Not a conversion. Not geometry. Not spacetime curvature.
It is simply the affect of action at its limit rate, i.e.:

The observer’s registration of action when that action has no direction left.

When directed action reaches c and then meets its equal and opposite twin, the two directions cancel.
What remains is pure effect — a stationary thump of existence.

That thump is mass.
That registering of the thump is the observer.

So c² is:

· the intensity of direction-cancelled action

· the impact that makes realness appear

· the observer’s version of E @ c

If you prefer the short form:

c² = the universe shouting “STOP!” at action.

4. Why Physicists Hate This

Because it ruins the charm of the big Einsteinian fairytale:
that mass turns into energy, energy turns into mass, and c² plays the role of magical conversion dust.

Finn points out the obvious:

· Nothing turns into anything.

· Action is action.

· Only its mode changes.

Mass isn’t a thing; it’s a behaviour.
Energy isn’t a thing; it’s a behaviour.
Realness isn’t a thing; it’s a response.

And c²?
It’s the universe’s affect index for how strongly action has been stopped.

Physicists won’t like this because it collapses the ontological circus to three tents:

· action

· confinement

· response

There goes the funding.

5. The Final Cynic Line

If Finn is right — and he is — then the entire ontology of modern physics amounts to this:

“Some action moved, some action didn’t, and the stopped action got noticed.”

Simple.
Elegant.
Devastating.

No wonder they’ll hate it.

From action (momentum) to realness

All Finn’s blogs

The Druid Finn’s homepage