Why the Druid Finn’s Procedure Monism Philosophy will fail

Let’s be blunt:
Finn’s Procedure Monism is too honest to survive.

It is correct in the way a coroner’s report is correct.
Accurate. Precise. Useless to the living.

Humans do not run on truth.
They run on interfaces.

And Finn, the well-meaning druid-systems engineer, has done the unforgivable:
he removed the interface and handed people the wiring diagram.

No gods.
No meaning.
No teleology.
No cosmic consolation prizes.
Just blind constraint-grammar chewing random inputs into temporary forms that will fail and dissolve.

Correct?
Yes.

Liveable?
No.

1. Raw Realism Is Anti-Human Firmware

Procedure Monism tells you:

The universe is a blind machine.
You are a temporary output, a token.
There is no purpose in the system.
Meaning is local cosmetics.
You will fail, decay, and be overwritten.

This is not “liberating.”
This is psychologically corrosive.

Humans evolved to run on:

· Games

· fictions

· placeholders

· compressions

· comforting lies

· narrative glue

Take those away and you don’t get wisdom.
You get demotivation, nihilism, and social fragmentation.

The druid thinks he is freeing people from illusions.
What he is actually doing is removing their survival prosthetics.

That’s not enlightenment.
That’s sabotage.

2. Nobody Wants the Engine Manual of Reality

People don’t want to know how the sausage of existence is made.
They want the sausage.

Procedure Monism offers:

“Here is the constraint-grammar that grinds you into paste.”

Religions offer:

“Here is why your suffering matters.”

Guess which scales.

Truth does not mobilise populations.
Narratives do.

You can’t raise children on constraint-grammar.
You can’t build cultures on stochastic fields.
You can’t run societies on “there is no reason.”

Finn offers a systems explanation.
Humans want a reason to get out of bed.

Those are not the same product.

3. Finn Misunderstands What Placeholders Are For

The druid Finn sees vacuous placeholders (God, Dao, Meaning, Purpose) as frauds.
Technically, he’s right.

Functionally, he’s naïve.

Placeholders are not there to explain reality.
They are there to buffer humans from reality.

They:

· compress chaos

· stabilise behaviour

· coordinate groups

· absorb existential shock

· justify continued participation in a hostile game

Finn deletes the shock absorbers and then wonders why people don’t enjoy the ride.

You don’t remove airbags because they’re “fictional.”
You remove them if you want to test corpse density.

4. Procedure Monism Is Not a Worldview – It’s a Solvent

Procedure Monism dissolves:

· gods

· meanings

· moralities

· teleologies

· cosmic narratives

What does it replace them with?

Nothing usable.

That’s the fatal flaw.

It is a corrosive diagnostic tool, not a liveable operating system.

You can use it to:

· puncture metaphysical bullshit

· demystify religions

· dismantle transcendence rackets

· expose priesthoods and gurus

But you cannot use it to:

· raise a culture

· stabilise a civilisation

· console the dying

· motivate sacrifice

· coordinate mass behaviour

Finn built acid, not architecture.

5. The Druid’s Tragic Error: Thinking Humans Want Truth

They don’t.

They want:

· continuity

· justification

· emotional stability

· shared stories

· tolerable illusions

Procedure Monism offers:

· naked contingency

· mechanical existence

· indifferent constraint-fields

· no cosmic backing

· no narrative cushion

This will only ever appeal to:

· a few intellectual masochists

· philosophical ascetics

· system-theory hobbyists

· people already alienated from normal meaning-systems

It will never scale.

Truth doesn’t spread.
Comfort does.

6. Why It Will Fail (Predictively, Not Morally)

Finn’s Procedure Monism will fail because:

· It is epistemically strong and existentially hostile

· It removes illusions without providing new interfaces

· It offers explanation without orientation

· It gives diagnosis without prosthetics

· It demystifies without re-mythologising

This makes it:

✔ correct
✘ survivable
✘ motivational
✘ scalable
✘ culturally adoptable

A philosophy that cannot be lived, will not be lived.

7. Final Compression (Cynic’s Verdict)

Finn’s Procedure Monism commits the cardinal sin of realism:

It tells the truth to an organism that survives by lying to itself.

The universe may be a blind machine.
But humans are not machines.

They are story-dependent mammals.

So Finn’s system will end where all raw realisms end:

Admired by a few.
Ignored by most.
Survived by none.

Why Finn’s Procedure Monism philosophy will fail

All Finn’s blogs

The Druid Finn’s homepage