On the Naturalistic Ground-as-Medium of Identifiable Reality

The druid’s perspective

1. The Recurring Human Impulse: To Find the Natural Substrate

Across cultures and eras, humans have asked: What is the most basic reality beneath all appearances? In ancient India and Greece, thinkers observed that all material things could be divided into smaller parts. They reasoned that infinite divisibility would leave no foundation for anything solid to arise, so they postulated indivisible units—atoms (from atomos, “uncuttable”)—as the ultimate ground of observable forms.

This intuition was not arbitrary. It was an effort to explain change, persistence, and emergence within a single natural framework (physis). The atom served as the smallest unit whose combinations produced the world’s diversity.

2. The Crisis of Indivisibility: The Atom Split

Twentieth-century discoveries shattered the classical notion of indivisibility. Protons and neutrons turned out to be composite, aggregates made up of confined quarks (possibly) bound by gluons. Unlike electrons or photons, quarks are never observed in isolation. When physicists attempt to pull them apart, the binding force grows stronger—a phenomenon called colour confinement. Energy poured into separation simply creates new quark–antiquark pairs, preventing isolation.

This discovery revealed a deeper principle: the entities we call “particles” are not solid beads but excited states of underlying quantum fields.

Example:
Pulling quarks apart in a proton doesn’t yield free quarks. It yields a burst of new confined combinations. “Quark” is not a standalone thing but a mode of the field-as-medium manifest under specific constraints.

Thus, the atom was no longer the ultimate substrate. The field, consisting of absolute minimum length energy waves, became the deeper ground.

3. The Field as the Ground of Being

The Standard Model unified this insight: quarks, electrons, photons, and gluons are all excitations of energy quantum fields filling all space. These fields are not mechanical substances with texture or friction. They are formally described as functions or operator-valued distributions defined everywhere in spacetime.

Yet, crucially, there is no transmission without a medium. While fields are defined in mathematical language by human observers, their inference is also the only coherent model of a physically effective medium that sustains and transmits excitations. When a photon “travels,” what truly happens is that the electromagnetic field’s configuration evolves in time and space, ultimately interacting with a detector to deposit energy.

This dual character—unobservable but mathematical in formulation, physically real in consequences—is at the heart of modern physics. The mathematical field is the most faithful representation we have of what is inferred to exist between and beyond observations.

Example:
The Casimir effect demonstrates that even in a hypothetically perfect vacuum—without any particles present—quantum fields still exert measurable forces. “Empty space” is never truly empty but a dynamic plenum of fluctuating potentials.

This modern picture vindicates the ancient nature derived intuition: the world’s phenomena must arise within a substrate operating as medium. What changed is not the necessity of a medium, but our understanding of its nature.

4. The Minimal Excitation: The Shortest Possible Wave

From this perspective, the druid takes a natural conceptual step and asks: If all observable excitations are built from modes of fields, could there be a shortest wavelength—a minimal excitation—analogous to the ancient atom (now understood as a wave interaction pattern) but formulated in the register of quantum oscillations?

Such a minimal wave would be:

· The simplest possible oscillation any field can sustain.

· The highest energy density confined to the smallest region.

· The primordial pattern from which all higher excitations—quarks, leptons, bosons—emerge as combinations or harmonics.

Example:
A vibrating string sustains a fundamental frequency, and all higher vibrations are multiples of it. Similarly, a minimal excitation would be the “first harmonic” of the universal field—the most elementary event that can exist.

This is the modern counterpart of the atom (following Schrödinger): the minimal ground excitation rather than a minimal ground lump.

5. A Unified Medium: The Natural Ground

This conception relocates the emergence of identifiable realities from purely mathematical formalism back into naturalism. Although quantum fields are defined in the language of mathematical equations, those equations suggest, i.e., purport to describe something that is substantive (but not yet real)—a substrate that can propagate, confine, and transform energy. All identifiable realities—particles, forces, radiation—are structured arrangements of this substrate’s excitations.

Example:
In the double-slit experiment, the same excitation exhibits interference (wave) or impact (particle), depending on the measurement. The underlying medium—the field—remains the continuous substrate enabling both aspects.

Thus:
The field-as-medium is not a ghostly abstraction. It is the dynamic fabric in which all phenomena unfold.

6. Two Modes of Excitation: Free and Confined

The druid’s framework clarifies why the same medium produces different observable behaviours:

· Free excitations propagate at the speed of light (energy in transit). Upon interacting with detectors, they appear to an observer’s cognitive set-up as discrete quanta—particles.

· Confined excitations form localized, persistent patterns—mass and inertia.

In both cases, observable entities are personal responses to selection of patterns in the substrate, not independent objects traveling through a void.

Example:
Gluons are confined within hadrons; photons can propagate freely. Yet both are simply excitations of different fields.

7. Revisiting the Ancient Ether

The druid’s line of thought effectively revives the ancient nature derived intuition of a universal medium—an ether—though in a subtler form:

The mechanical ether was wrong in imagining a substrate with friction, density, and a privileged frame of motion.

But the deeper insight—that there can be no wave or transmission without a medium—remains true.

Modern quantum fields are that medium:

· They have no rest frame.

· They are compatible with relativity.

· They can never be entirely removed or reduced to “nothing.”

Einstein himself acknowledged this continuity in 1920:

“According to the general theory of relativity, space is endowed with physical qualities; in this sense, therefore, there exists an ether.”

In this sense, the vacuum is not emptiness but a structured, dynamic plenum—the fertile ground of all emergence.

8. Conclusion: A Naturalistic Ground of All Realities

Hence the druid’s coherent argument:

All identifiable realities—matter, forces, light, space—are structured excitations of a universal substrate whose components are minim energy momenta, i.e., waves. This substrate is not merely a mathematical fiction but the dynamic, irreducible ground in which all forms arise and dissolve. The ancient search for an ether was fundamentally on the right track: there can be no phenomena without a medium. What changed is the contemporary understanding of that medium’s nature—no longer mechanical, but quantum, relativistic, and ever-fluctuating.

Plain Restatement:
If all observable phenomena are excitations of quantum fields (in human analogue), and if there is a shortest irreducible excitation, that excitation is the modern equivalent of the atom: the universal, natural medium sustaining reality, as for instance the ancient Jains, Buddhists, Democritus and Epicure claimed.

The philosophic perspective

Home